Tuesday, February 16, 2016

The Challenge to Care in Schools (And Not Get Fired)

I admire Nel Noddings greatly, and her Challenge to Care in Schools has been instrumental in shaping my own teaching philosophy. But acting out a teaching philosophy based on caring is becoming increasingly difficult. Not only are students treated as numbers, as you've heard from a million and a half other education bloggers, but so are teachers.

Teachers are no longer allowed to be whole people. I'm not talking about the social media policies requiring that teachers keep their (public social media) lives clean and free of cursing, drinking, promiscuity, and other "sins." Personally, I think most people should follow such rules, if for no other reason than that I don't particularly want to know who you shagged last night or how much beer you had beforehand.

Rather, I'm referring to the fact that teachers are expected, even required, to leave elements of themselves at home, far away from the classroom. Because the slightest comment about my social, political, or moral beliefs might cause an uproar or, worse, a lawsuit. If some states (I'm looking at you, Kansas) have their way, teaching anything that any parent or student deems "objectionable" can result in a lawsuit, and you can bet your sweet behind that the teacher would lose. Not to mention the risks teachers take on a daily basis in order to make students feel cared for.

Cartoon from kevinspear.com

I call everyone "honey," and I'm blessed to be in a school district where that's generally okay. But I would be fired in a heartbeat in others. I risk firing every day when I give a student a much-needed hug, slip them an encouraging note, allow a student to enter my room and close the door for a private conversation, or share a bit of who I am for the purpose of connecting with my students. Even calling them "my kids" is dangerous, even though they are, and I love them as if they were really mine. In short, I technically shouldn't show my students love because of legal, legislative, or administrative rules and threats.

So every morning, I and thousands of other teachers, put on our "professional dress" and take off our "controversial" selves. Because heaven forbid our students see us as anything approaching human. But then we slip in little signs of love throughout the day - a pat on the back here, a snack for a hungry student there - because, and this should be no surprise, we are not robots. Teachers are a special breed built to love every student who comes through the door. Even the ones who throw chairs and scissors at them while screaming obscenities (yes, it really happened, just not to me). It's just what we do.

No comments:

Post a Comment